Essay Rubrics, Explained Row by Row

Each rubric page explains what earns every point, with examples, and links to its grader once that grader opens.

AP® essay rubrics

AP history and AP English essays are scored on analytic rubrics: separate rows, each worth its own points.^3,4 Each page explains every point in our own words, with an example that earns it and the misses that cost it.

LEQ rubricThe long essay question, scored out of 6 in APUSH, AP World and AP Euro.6 points · 4 rows
DBQ rubricThe document-based question, scored out of 7, with the document counts.7 points · 6 rows
AP Lang rubricSynthesis, rhetorical analysis and argument, each scored out of 6.6 points · 3 rows

SAQ and AP Lit rubric pages are on the way. Our AP graders open once each one passes our accuracy check against experienced AP teachers; every AP rubric page has a form to get one email when that happens.

College essay rubrics

Colleges don't publish a shared scoring rubric for application essays, so ours are our own, built around what admissions offices commonly say they look for. They live in the college graders for now.

Grade your essay

BetaFirst essay free

Your essaySample essay. Paste yours.

73 wordsPlain text is fine

Rubric

The assignment or essay question(optional)

We never train AI on your essay or rewrite it. We don't save grades made without an account. Our AI provider keeps a copy for up to 30 days. Account essays auto-delete after 30 days, or delete them now. For ages 13+.

The general essay rubric

For class essays with no exam rubric: five rows that most classroom rubrics share, each scored 0 to 4, for 20 points on our practice scale. It draws on widely used writing guidance.^1,2

GradeLamp general essay rubric, version 1.1.0, updated 6 Nov 2026. Our own wording; not an official rubric of any school or exam.
Score	What it looks like
Thesis0–4 points
4 points	A clear, specific, arguable thesis that answers the assignment and guides the whole essay.
3 points	A clear thesis that answers the assignment but is somewhat broad or predictable.
2 points	A thesis is present but vague, overly general, or only partly answers the assignment.
1 point	The main idea has to be inferred or is unclear.
0 points	No identifiable thesis or main idea.
Evidence0–4 points
4 points	Relevant, specific, well-chosen evidence supports every main point and is presented accurately.
3 points	Relevant evidence supports most points; some of it is general.
2 points	Evidence is thin, general, or only loosely relevant to some points.
1 point	Little evidence; mostly assertion.
0 points	No supporting evidence.
Analysis0–4 points
4 points	Consistently explains how and why the evidence supports the thesis, with insight beyond the obvious.
3 points	Explains most evidence clearly, though some explanation is brief or predictable.
2 points	Some explanation, but much of the evidence is summarised or left unexplained.
1 point	Mostly summary or restatement with little explanation.
0 points	No analysis.
Organization0–4 points
4 points	Logical, purposeful structure with an effective introduction and conclusion, focused paragraphs and smooth transitions.
3 points	Clear overall structure; some paragraphs or transitions could be tighter.
2 points	Some organization, but paragraphs wander, repeat, or appear in an unclear order.
1 point	Little clear organization.
0 points	No discernible structure.
Language and Mechanics0–4 points
4 points	Clear, varied sentences and precise word choice; very few errors in grammar, spelling or punctuation.
3 points	Generally clear and correct, with some minor errors or repetitive sentence patterns.
2 points	Noticeable errors or awkward sentences that sometimes distract the reader.
1 point	Frequent errors that often obscure meaning.
0 points	Errors make the essay very hard to read.

Bands on our practice scale: 0-9 Beginning · 10-13 Developing · 14-17 Proficient · 18-20 Ready to submit.

One page, every level.

Use it when your teacher hasn't given you a rubric. If they have, their rubric wins. Scores are practice estimates, not grades. The essay grader scores your draft on these five rows, quotes the sentences behind each score and gives one fix per row.

Reading a rubric

How to read an analytic rubric

A holistic rubric gives one overall score. An analytic rubric splits the essay into rows (thesis, evidence, reasoning and so on) and scores each one separately, then adds them up. That is why an AP history essay can earn the thesis point and miss the context point: each row is judged on its own.

Some rows act as gates. In AP Lang, a synthesis essay that uses fewer than two sources scores 0 for evidence and commentary whatever its other strengths; in a DBQ, the second document point needs four documents used in the argument. Find the gates first, because they cap everything after them.

Read each row from the top level down and ask what your draft would need to move up one level. That one move is usually a better revision plan than polishing everything at once.

GradeLamp grades the same way: the AI scores each row against these descriptors and quotes your essay as evidence, then our code applies the caps and adds the total, so the arithmetic is never a guess. Every score is a practice estimate, not an official one. The details are in how AI essay grading works.

Questions

FAQ

What is an analytic rubric?

A rubric that scores separate rows, such as thesis, evidence and reasoning, and adds them up, instead of giving one overall impression score. AP English and AP history essays use analytic rubrics.

Are these the official College Board rubrics?

They are our plain-English explanations of the published College Board scoring criteria, with links to the originals. College Board is not affiliated with GradeLamp.

Can I grade against my own rubric?

Not yet. Custom rubrics, built with our rubric maker, come with the teacher plans. Until then you can grade against any of the built-in rubrics.

Sources and notes

Facts on this page last checked 6 November 2026. Rubric descriptions are our own wording; follow the links for the official originals. Scores from GradeLamp are practice estimates, not official scores.

GradeLamp · www.gradelamp.com/rubrics

GradeLamp general essay rubric

20 points on our practice scale. Five rows, each scored 0 to 4. Not an official rubric of any school or exam.

Row	4 points	3 points	2 points	1 point	0 points
A. Thesis	A clear, specific, arguable thesis that answers the assignment and guides the whole essay.	A clear thesis that answers the assignment but is somewhat broad or predictable.	A thesis is present but vague, overly general, or only partly answers the assignment.	The main idea has to be inferred or is unclear.	No identifiable thesis or main idea.
B. Evidence	Relevant, specific, well-chosen evidence supports every main point and is presented accurately.	Relevant evidence supports most points; some of it is general.	Evidence is thin, general, or only loosely relevant to some points.	Little evidence; mostly assertion.	No supporting evidence.
C. Analysis	Consistently explains how and why the evidence supports the thesis, with insight beyond the obvious.	Explains most evidence clearly, though some explanation is brief or predictable.	Some explanation, but much of the evidence is summarised or left unexplained.	Mostly summary or restatement with little explanation.	No analysis.
D. Organization	Logical, purposeful structure with an effective introduction and conclusion, focused paragraphs and smooth transitions.	Clear overall structure; some paragraphs or transitions could be tighter.	Some organization, but paragraphs wander, repeat, or appear in an unclear order.	Little clear organization.	No discernible structure.
E. Language and Mechanics	Clear, varied sentences and precise word choice; very few errors in grammar, spelling or punctuation.	Generally clear and correct, with some minor errors or repetitive sentence patterns.	Noticeable errors or awkward sentences that sometimes distract the reader.	Frequent errors that often obscure meaning.	Errors make the essay very hard to read.
Total	20 points: the row scores added together

GradeLamp general essay rubric, version 1.1.0, checked 6 Nov 2026. Sources: www.aacu.org/initiatives/value-initiative/value-rubrics/value-rubrics-written-communication; writingcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/thesis-statements/; writingcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/evidence/.